The Third and Fourth Church: A Story of Resilience
The magnificent church that stands today is the architectural and spiritual anchor of Pointe-Claire Village. Its story is not one of a single construction, but a remarkable saga of misfortune, determination, and a community’s unwavering resolve to build and rebuild its most sacred space.
The fourth church, circa 1907
(Source: Bibliothèque et Archives nationales du Québec)
The Vision for a New Church (1857 – 1881)
By the mid-19th century, the second church was in need of extensive repairs. More urgently, the practice of burying bodies beneath its floor had created a public health hazard. In response to a petition from parishioners, Montreal’s bishop, Monseigneur Ignace Bourget, approved the construction of a new church in 1857.
The commission was given to Victor Bourgeau, one of Montreal’s most prominent religious architects. His neo-gothic design was based on his recently completed Saint-Pierre-Apôtre church. However, the project was beset by challenges, including an economic crisis and a change in contractors. After a long and arduous process, just as the new (third) church was nearing completion, disaster struck.
The Great Fire of 1881
On Easter Sunday, April 17, 1881, a fire broke out in the old second church. Fanned by strong winds, the flames quickly spread to the nearly finished new structure. In a devastating blow to the community, both buildings were burned to the ground, leaving only their stone foundations.
The third Church, circa 1881
(unknown source)
The fourth Church, 2004
(Source: SSPPC Archives)
Rising from the Ashes: The Fourth Church (1882 – Today)
Despite the shock and devastation, the community resolved to rebuild immediately. Aided by an insurance settlement, work began on what is now known as the fourth church.
Constructed on the same site and using stones salvaged from the ruins, the new church followed Victor Bourgeau’s original plans to the letter. In a remarkable display of determination, the magnificent building we see today—a faithful reconstruction of the one that was lost—was completed in 1883, securing its place as the enduring heart of the village.
Explore Our Heritage in Depth
The story of Pointe-Claire’s churches is rich with architectural detail and community history. Explore our publications to learn more.